Is barter more ethical than buy?

Is barter more ethical than buy?

It is an interesting question and perhaps a little more complex than I thought initially.

On a first look the answer is yes. Barter is good as people do not exchange funds they trade an item or  service in our case alternative medicine for some goods or services we have such as our duck eggs.

duck eggs-2000

It is a win win for those involved we get looked after and it helps to offset the feed bill for our ducks and chickens. The alternative practitioner gets the duck eggs he needs as some members of his family are allergic to chicken eggs. They are fresh guaranteed organic and better value (or so he tells me than the ones he gets through commercial elements)

Add to that our ducks have a much better life than most commercial fowl and raised in what I look at as pretty sustainable way.

Often it is what you have in excess that is swapped so it is way of ensuring that things are not wasted and are shared around to those who need it. Which is something the world can most definitely do with.

And finally as was pointed out to me this morning by friend who was staying for a few days in Melbourne with us while he attended a course.

He noted I was cleaning the duck eggs for the appointment tonight and commented that bartering makes you more accountable for what you are trading. Handing over cash is easy getting cash is easy but it can lead to devaluing of what you do or make or sell. Bartering where the direct value of a product or service you have is based on the quality vs. the quality of the thing you are getting in return makes you really look at it and make sure it is as good as you can make it. Having pride in that item or service

On the flip side you are effectively not paying your dues to society. And this is where it gets tricky. Because in reality you are not paying your taxes to the government it is to society that the taxes go through the medium of the government. We are taxed so that import things like social welfare, infrastructure and really important reforms like the NDIS (national Disability Insurance Scheme) can be payed for.

It also means that people have a job to allow them to buy goods and services that couldn’t be bartered for.

We also pay for a lot of stuff we don’t like, as an example we subsidise already wealthy companies (corporate welfare) and a governments that we often don’t really believe is worth what we are putting in.

So it is a balancing act. I think that swapping items and services is great if done on a sustainable level,

And here is the kicker it is a sustainable level we are talking about. If everyone keeps below the tax free threshold and barters the rest that sounds great for them. For society probably not so great in the medium or long term. And at the end of the day ‘you are the society’ and a sustainable society is what we should all be interested in.


One thought on “Is barter more ethical than buy?

  1. Knew you’d get over that writer’s block 🙂

    I agree completely with you. I’m not a believer in buying a plot of land in the middle of nowhere and being completely self-reliant because to me that is a selfish dream. As human kind has evolved we’ve done so as part of a society, community or hive (delete as appropriate). We have relied upon larger and larger support networks, from family units and small tribes, to towns, cities, nations and governments.

    To me this means that those who are stronger or more able have a responsibility to pay their dues and support the care of those who are less able. This might be on a local scale, or on a national one,

    On a national scale, the way the system works for those of us who are employed is that we exchange some of our earnings to provide those support networks on a large scale. Support networks that we too benefit from. Is this not bartering? 🙂

    Bartering n a community, local level and can work fantastically. It enables us to exchange the skills we do have, to benefit from the skills we don’t. There is no reason also that it cannot involve the provision of non-essential care, or even in some cases essential care. Local doctors can be retained by a community who provide them with housing, water and food, as well as maintenance and repair work etc when needed. This example is still bartering, and still provides us with the support we need.

    I think the key thing with bartering is that it’s the basis of our financial systems. One good is seen to have a lower or higher value than another, based on the needs and desires of the parties involved at that point in time. All we’ve done is exchange one side of the bartering process with money rather than something tangible.

    That was a bit rambly I know, but I really need some sleep! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s